Licensed Insurance Customer Service Representative – Property & Casualty

We’re a third-generation insurance agency, proudly serving our community since 1950. For over 70 years, we’ve specialized in personal and small commercial insurance, earning trust through exceptional service and reliable guidance. Our team of licensed professionals averages 25+ years of experience—and we’re excited to welcome the next member to our family. The Role: We’re seeking a Licensed Property & Casualty Insurance Professional who is passionate about building client relationships, providing outstanding service, and supporting sales opportunities.

Employment Type:

Full-time, W2 Salary Range: $40,000 – $55,000 per year, plus bonus opportunities Location: In-office, Columbus, OH

Why You’ll Love Working With Us

We value our team as much as we value our clients.

Here’s what you can look forward to:

• 15 days PTO after 90 days
• Paid holidays
• Short-term disability coverage
• Paid continuing education
• Retirement plan with employer matching
• Bonus opportunities
• A supportive, experienced team and a warm, professional work environment

What We’re Looking For

Active Property & Casualty Insurance License (P&C) 1+ years of insurance agency experience Proficiency with computer systems and software Strong communication skills (both verbal & written) Detail-oriented, self-motivated, and independent Calm, professional demeanor in all situations Ability to build rapport and assist with sales opportunities

How to Apply

Ready to join a company where tradition meets excellence? Please complete our required Innermetrix Assessment here: https://profiles.innermetrix.com/VO/7eb75783/en We look forward to welcoming you to our team and continuing our long-standing tradition of service and excellence!

Learn More

https://www.coonfareinsurance.com/

Job Type: Full-time

Pay: $45,000.00 - $55,000.00 per year

Benefits:

• 401(k) matching
• Paid time off

Work Location: In person