Personal Lines Producer

Personal Lines Producer

Protect What Matters, Build Relationships, Make a Difference

At Your Policy, we live by four Core Values: People First, Do What You Love, Deliver What You Promise, and Balance is Key. These principles shape how we work, connect, and serve—building meaningful relationships and creating a culture of care and accountability.

Our mission is to make insurance simple, transparent, and personal; removing the stress and complexity so our customers can make confident, informed choices about their coverage.

Less hassle. More peace of mind.

Because our agency is continuously growing, we are always looking for exceptional talent to join our team. This is an evergreen opening - we hire top-tier producers year-round to support our expanding client base.

Location:

This position will start remote to allow you to maximize your business development. The goal is to eventually transition to hybrid after 6-9 months

Job Description

We’re looking for a motivated, relationship-focused Personal Lines Producer to join our growing team. In this role, you’ll help clients protect their homes, cars, and other valuables — and you’ll do it with empathy, expertise, and integrity.

You’ll build lasting relationships, grow your book of business, and make an impact by helping people find coverage that truly fits their lives.

If you genuinely care about people and love connecting through conversation, you’ll thrive here.

Daily Responsibilities

• Grow your book — generate new business through referrals, networking, community outreach, and digital channels.

• Understand your clients — assess coverage needs and recommend personalized solutions for home, auto, renters, umbrella, and more.

• Deliver peace of mind — clearly explain policy options, exclusions, and pricing in a way clients can truly understand.

• Retain and nurture — maintain regular communication with clients to ensure satisfaction and identify coverage gaps or new needs.

• Cross-sell smartly — identify opportunities within existing accounts to expand protection.

• Stay organized — document all communications, quotes, and policies accurately in the agency management system.

• Hit your goals — consistently meet or exceed sales and retention targets while building lasting relationships.

• Lead with professionalism — protect client confidentiality and represent Your Policy with integrity and care.

What You Bring

• 1–2+ years of experience in personal lines insurance or related sales role.

• Established Center of Influences or a plan to obtain multiple one's quickly

• Active Property & Casualty license (or ability to obtain within 90 days).

• A proven ability to connect with clients and close business in a competitive market.

• Knowledge of key personal insurance products — home, auto, renters, and umbrella.

• Excellent communication, problem-solving, and people skills.

• Organized, self-motivated, and goal-driven.

• Comfortable with CRM and agency management systems

Agent Support & Sales Perks

To help you stay focused on growing your book, we provide several internal advantages and supplemental lead sources:

• Direct System Access: Full access to our phone system with inbound new business calls routed directly to agents.

• Supplemental Lead Pipelines: Access to existing pipelines from former agents, win-back lists for past clients, and internal cross-sell opportunities.

• Network Jumpstart: We provide a lender referral list of 100+ contacts in the area to help you proactively build your own professional network.

Why You’ll Love Working Here

• Competitive base + commission potential — your effort drives your earnings.

• Health, dental, and vision insurance after 30 days.

• 401(k) eligibility after 500 hours.

• Paid time off + holidays to keep your balance in check.

• Ongoing training, development, and continuing education support.

• A positive, people-first culture that values your growth and celebrates your wins.

At Your Policy, we know insurance is more than protection — it’s about people.
Every day, our Producers help clients feel confident, secure, and supported.

If you’re ready to grow your career, earn what you’re worth, and make an impact with a team that truly cares — we’d love to meet you.